Q 2: It is claimed that if a person does not find a Sutrah (barrier placed in front of a person praying), it is not enough to draw a line in front of them with a staff? What is the ruling on this?A:
Scholars differ regarding
the permissibility of drawing a line in front of a person offering Salah (Prayer) (Part No. 7; Page No. 81)?to act as a Sutrah for them, and whether this would be enough if the person does not find a staff.
Sa`id ibn Jubayr,
Ahmad permitted it, while
Abu Hanifah disapproved it.
Al-Shafi`y permitted it when he was in
Iraq, but when he came to
Egypt he said, "A person should not draw a line unless it is a Sunnah to follow. The reason for the differing opinions was their debate over the authenticity of the Hadith which
was narrated by Imam
Abu Dawud and
Abu Hurayrah that the Prophet (peace be upon him) stated:
When you offer Salah, you should place something in front of you. If you can find nothing, use your staff. If you have no staff, draw a line and there is no harm if anyone passes in front of you.
Ibn Hibban and
Al-Bayhaqy. Al-Hafizh ibn Hajar said in his book Bulugh Al-Maram, "Those who claim it is Mudtarib (a Hadith with disagreement over a transmitter or the text) are wrong; it is Hasan (a Hadith whose chain of narration contains a narrator with weak exactitude, but is free from eccentricity or blemish)."
Sufyan ibn `Uyaynah,
Al-Baghawy and others ranked this Hadith as Da`if (weak); they did not consider it is enough to draw a line as a Sutrah in Salah. The first opinion is stronger, according to the mentioned Hadith.May Allah grant us success. May peace and blessings be upon our Prophet Muhammad, his family, and Companions.